Corey O’Connor Ousts Progressive Mayor Ed Gainey in Pittsburgh Primary Upset

In a stunning upset, Pittsburgh’s Democratic mayoral primary saw Corey O’Connor, backed by the party’s "old guard" and even some Republicans, defeat progressive incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey. O’Connor, son of the late former Mayor Bob O’Connor, leveraged substantial fundraising and a coalition of traditional Democrats to reclaim the city’s political helm.

Gainey, the Steel City’s first Black mayor, had positioned himself as a progressive force, securing the 2026 NFL Draft for a projected $200 million economic boost and spearheading initiatives like community policing and affordable housing growth. Yet, O’Connor’s campaign, bolstered by groups like Common Sense Change Action, framed itself as the pragmatic choice, emphasizing police resourcing and downtown revitalization.

"This isn’t about labels—it’s about Pittsburgh’s future," O’Connor declared, dismissing progressive versus establishment debates. His victory signals a shift, as voters favored his promise to steer the city back to its roots over Gainey’s bold, divisive reforms, like his refusal to cooperate with federal ICE operations, which drew sharp criticism from Republican Sen. David McCormick.

Gainey’s tenure wasn’t without triumphs. Under his leadership, Pittsburgh led Pennsylvania in population growth and added 1,600 affordable housing units. His collaboration with Gov. Josh Shapiro brought $600 million for downtown renewal. Still, O’Connor’s nostalgic appeal and strategic alliances proved too strong.

As Pittsburgh looks ahead, this race underscores a broader tension: progress versus tradition, with O’Connor’s win suggesting voters crave stability in turbulent times.