Meghan Markle Sends Handwritten Note to Podcaster Amid Netflix Show Criticism

Sarah Johnson
March 22, 2025
Brief
Meghan Markle surprised podcaster Amanda Hirsch with a handwritten note after criticism of her Netflix show 'With Love, Meghan,' sparking renewed conversation about Markle's public image.
Meghan Markle surprised podcaster Amanda Hirsch, host of "Not Skinny But Not Fat," with a handwritten note after Hirsch expressed concerns for the Duchess of Sussex following criticism of her Netflix show, "With Love, Meghan."
Hirsch had previously shared her worries on Instagram, writing, "You guys, I'm scared for Meghan," as the show's trailer sparked accusations of being "forced" and lacking relatability.
Two weeks after the premiere, Markle sent a note that radiated confidence and humor. It read, "Dear Amanda, I heard you were feeling scared. Don't be! This is the fun part – let's enjoy it." Talk about flipping the narrative with style!
Hirsch, clearly blown away, shared her reaction on Instagram: "Beyond shook. Beyond spiraling. Did I smell the paper? Yes! Do I want my own monogram? Yes. Am I absolutely flabbergasted and obsessed? F--- YES. @meghan, you have a fan for life." She even created a special box to store Markle's letter, calling it an "extra special" keepsake.
Despite Hirsch’s initial concerns that the show might come across as inauthentic or overly staged, Markle's confidence in her work seems undeterred. The show features the Duchess sharing recipes and hosting tips alongside celebrity friends and chefs. However, early reviews haven’t been kind. Critics, including royal experts, labeled the series "mundane" and "cringey," with one even likening Markle to a "modern Stepford Wife." Yikes.
Still, there are voices of optimism. Former royal photographer Ian Pelham Turner believes Markle just needs time to shine, praising the show’s cinematography and culinary content. Branding expert Doug Eldridge also chimed in, suggesting that Markle’s recent openness about her family life in Montecito, California, could be a step in the right direction.
Markle described her home life with Prince Harry and their two children, Archie and Lilibet, as "close-knit" and shared her love for family moments, including cooking in a kitchen bustling with over 80 crew members. Eldridge advised Markle to keep the focus on her family and avoid the "victim marketing" that hasn’t worked for her in the past.
While "With Love, Meghan" has been renewed for a second season, whether the Duchess can win over audiences remains to be seen. As one branding expert put it, "America loves a comeback story." Markle now has the chance for a reset—and the ball is in her court.
Topics
Editor's Comments
Okay, Meghan sending a handwritten note to a podcaster is a power move that’s equal parts charming and gutsy. Let’s be real—her show may be struggling in the relatability department, but this gesture shows she’s got a knack for winning people over one letter at a time. Maybe she should add 'pen pal extraordinaire' to her résumé. Also, the critics calling her a 'modern Stepford Wife'? That's a bit harsh—give the woman some room to breathe!
Like this article? Share it with your friends!
If you find this article interesting, feel free to share it with your friends!
Thank you for your support! Sharing is the greatest encouragement for us.