Pitching Phenom Paul Skenes Takes a Swing at Automated Strikezone: 'I Like the Human Aspect of the Game'

The debate over the introduction of an automated strikezone in Major League Baseball continues to heat up, and Paul Skenes, the Pittsburgh Pirates’ acclaimed pitcher, is clearly on the side of tradition. “I like the human aspect of the game,” Skenes stated recently, making his stance loud and clear.

MLB's move towards automation has been gradual but persistent. Players were given the ability to challenge balls and strikes during this past spring training, a system that's been tested in the minors for years. Commissioner Rob Manfred has suggested we could see the automated strikezone in regular-season games by 2026. However, Skenes is relieved it’s not a reality just yet.

"There are games where the umpire's zone is big, and there are games where the umpire's zone is small," Skenes explained. "With an automatic strikezone, framing becomes irrelevant, which pretty much eliminates a critical skill for catchers. I do have mixed feelings, but I appreciate the human element, even if it’s not perfect." A fair point—baseball is as much about its quirks as its precision.

Under the new system, teams are allowed two challenges per game, which they can retain if successful. Challenges must come immediately from the batter, pitcher, or catcher, without any outside help. Some players and fans feel this keeps the spirit of the game alive, but not everyone is convinced.

Paul Skenes isn’t the only star pitcher expressing skepticism. Future Hall of Famer Max Scherzer recently chimed in, saying, "I think major league umpires are really good. . . . Are we actually improving the game? Do we really need to disrupt it this much?" Scherzer’s sentiment doubles down on the idea that baseball is, at its heart, a human game.

Manfred’s tenure has been marked by sweeping changes to modernize baseball, including larger bases, pitch timers, and shift limits, all introduced in 2023. These adjustments have proven popular, with attendance numbers rising over the last two years. However, the automated strikezone seems to be striking a raw nerve with some traditionalists.

Skenes, meanwhile, continues to make waves on and off the field. Named the National League Rookie of the Year in 2024, he achieved an impressive 1.96 ERA and ranked third in Cy Young Award voting. His rookie card recently sold for $1.1 million—more than his current $875,000 salary. Clearly, the ace is already a fan favorite, and his opinions carry weight in the baseball world.