Stephen A. Smith Speaks Out on Shannon Sharpe Assault Allegations: 'Sad Situation' Unfolds

Sarah Johnson
April 23, 2025
Shannon Sharpe, NFL Hall of Famer and high-profile sports commentator, is facing serious legal fire after being accused of sexual assault, battery, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The accusations have landed Sharpe in a $50 million civil lawsuit, sending shockwaves through the sports and media world.
Sharpe has come out swinging, labeling the allegations a "shakedown" and even releasing explicit messages allegedly sent to him by his accuser. The legal showdown is also making headlines because the accuser's attorney, Tony Buzbee, has represented several big-name clients in similar high-profile cases, including the women who accused NFL quarterback Deshaun Watson and even celebrities like Jay-Z and Diddy. Clearly, this is not Buzbee's first rodeo—or courtroom battle.
Amid the uproar, Stephen A. Smith, Sharpe's co-host on ESPN's "First Take," finally addressed the controversy on his podcast. Smith called the situation "sad," describing Sharpe as a friend who's "overcome a lot" and emphasizing that ESPN and its parent company Disney are "taking this matter very, very seriously." According to Smith, he spoke with Sharpe, who "emphatically proclaims his innocence," but Smith also made it clear he's reserving judgment until more facts come out.
Smith didn't hold back on his critique of Sharpe's legal strategy. While he gets why Sharpe is defending himself publicly, Smith admits sharing explicit messages and the accuser's name made for an "uncomfortable" PR move, and he's not convinced it's the smartest legal play. Sometimes, the hardest thing for anyone in the spotlight is to just zip it and let the lawyers do their thing— but apparently, that's not the playbook Sharpe is following right now.
As for Sharpe's job at ESPN, Smith says the network brass are closely monitoring the situation, with ESPN chairman Jimmy Pitaro stressing that they'll move forward only after gathering all the facts. In a "perfect world," Smith hopes the case goes the way of a recent Jay-Z lawsuit—dropped, with Sharpe free to continue his career. But with both sides digging in their heels, he admits there's no telling how this will end.
The complaint against Sharpe alleges a pattern of manipulation, threats, and ultimately, rape, describing deeply disturbing details about their relationship. Sharpe's legal team, meanwhile, maintains that the relationship was consensual and that the messages show the nature of their connection. They also acknowledge that Sharpe offered a $10 million settlement—an offer the accuser declined.
The case appears destined for a long, messy battle. Buzbee claims to have damning video evidence, while Sharpe says he's the target of a calculated attack. Both sides are entrenched, and the sports world is left holding its breath for what comes next.
As Smith put it, "Only time will tell what the truth is." For now, the only thing clear is that this is a PR and legal nightmare that no one would wish on their "First Take" co-host—unless your idea of a good time is a front-row seat to a legal circus.
Editor's Comments
Honestly, this drama has more plot twists than a season of 'Hard Knocks.' Sometimes it feels like ESPN needs a legal analyst on set just to keep score. If Tony Buzbee ever opens a frequent litigator program, Sharpe might just earn platinum status by the end of this. The real MVP here? The popcorn industry.
— Sarah Johnson
Like this article? Share it with your friends!
If you find this article interesting, feel free to share it with your friends!
Thank you for your support! Sharing is the greatest encouragement for us.