Frisco Murder Suspect Karmelo Anthony to Graduate High School Despite Charges

In a controversial decision, Karmelo Anthony, an 18-year-old charged with the first-degree murder of high school track star Austin Metcalf, will graduate from Centennial High School in Frisco, Texas. The stabbing, which occurred at a track meet on April 2, stemmed from a dispute over Anthony’s presence in a rival team’s tent. While Anthony’s supporters claim self-defense, legal experts suggest this defense faces significant hurdles.

Graduation Amid Charges
Anthony will receive his diploma but is barred from the May 22 ceremony, a move Frisco Independent School District (ISD) Superintendent Mike Waldrip clarified clarified after rumors swirled about Anthony’s participation. Waldrip condemned what he called “fearmongering” and “media vitriol,” emphasizing that no student charged with a serious felony can attend graduation. He urged the community to focus on celebrating the Class of 2025.

Advocacy and Outrage
Dominique Alexander, speaking for Anthony’s family, hailed the graduation decision as a “moment of dignity” achieved through advocacy. However, the case has sparked heated public debate, with racial undertones. Alexander compared Anthony to Kyle Rittenhouse and Daniel Penny, who won self-defense cases, and accused detractors of bigotry. Meanwhile, Austin’s father, Jeff Metcalf, has faced harassment, including a swatting incident at his home.

Legal Challenges Ahead
Anthony’s self-defense claim hinges on allegations that Metcalf pushed him, but former prosecutor Julie Rendelman called it an “uphill battle” based on current evidence. As the case unfolds, Frisco grapples with grief, division, and the complexities of justice.