Maine Senate Rejects Ban on Trans Athletes in Girls' Sports Amid Legal Clash
Sarah Johnson
June 14, 2025
Brief
Maine Senate rejects bill to ban transgender athletes from girls' sports, sparking legal battles and public outcry over fairness and federal mandates.
In a heated battle over fairness in sports, the Maine Senate has voted down bill LD 1134, which aimed to exclude biologically male transgender athletes from competing in girls' sports. This decision, made on Thursday, underscores a deepening rift between state leadership and federal directives, particularly in light of President Donald Trump's executive order earlier this year pushing for the exclusion of men from women’s sports.
The rejection of the bill isn’t just a local skirmish; it’s part of a broader conflict. The U.S. Department of Justice has already slapped Maine with a lawsuit for refusing to comply with federal guidelines on maintaining girls' sports as female-only. A trial date for this legal showdown is set for April 1, 2026, promising more drama down the line.
Voices of dissent are loud and clear. Maine Republican lawmaker Laurel Libby didn’t hold back, blasting the Democrat majority for ignoring biological realities and the wishes of many Mainers. She argues that allowing biological males in girls' sports undermines fairness and invades personal spaces—a sentiment echoed by athletes and women’s rights activists who’ve been pushing for such bans for months.
Young athletes like Lucy Cheney and Carrlyn Buck from Presque Isle have shared their frustration, noting a perceived bias during legislative hearings. They described a lack of empathy from Democrats, with Cheney pointing out that lawmakers seemed more emotionally invested in pro-trans testimonies, while Buck felt their own concerns were met with hostility.
On the other side of the ring, Governor Janet Mills and state education officials stand firm, citing the Maine Human Rights Act as their guiding light for gender eligibility in sports. Despite mounting pressure—including a survey showing 63% of Maine voters support restricting girls' sports to biological females—Mills is ready to fight this battle in court, even if it means racking up legal fees on the taxpayers’ dime.
Interestingly, some Maine school districts aren’t waiting for the state to act. Two districts, MSAD No. 70 and RSU No. 24, have already tweaked their policies to keep transgender athletes out of girls' sports, signaling a grassroots push against the state’s stance.
This issue is far from settled. As Maine digs in its heels, the clash between state autonomy, federal law, and fundamental fairness in sports continues to heat up. Stay tuned—this is one game that’s nowhere near its final whistle.
Topics
Editor's Comments
Well, folks, Maine’s playing a game of legal dodgeball with the feds, and it’s clear they’re not afraid to take a hit. Governor Mills is ready to go toe-to-toe in court, but I can’t help wondering if she’s betting on a home-field advantage that doesn’t exist. Here’s a thought: if fairness in sports is the goal, maybe we should just let the athletes referee this one—after all, they’re the ones getting knocked out of the game. Speaking of, did you hear about the new Maine sport? It’s called ‘Policy Ping-Pong,’ and the ball’s been bouncing between state and federal courts for months!
Like this article? Share it with your friends!
If you find this article interesting, feel free to share it with your friends!
Thank you for your support! Sharing is the greatest encouragement for us.
