Michigan School Reverses Ban, Lets Christian Students Sing Worship Songs at Talent Show

In a classic schoolhouse plot twist, a Michigan elementary school reversed its decision after initially telling two Christian siblings they couldn't sing worship songs at the upcoming talent show.

Allegan Public Schools Superintendent James Antoine admitted that staff were unfamiliar with the legal guidelines on religious expression, clarifying, "Religious songs have been, and will continue to be, allowed at school events like talent shows." Turns out, the First Amendment is not just a suggestion!

The controversy started when West Ward Elementary officials told the siblings their song choices—Brandon Lake's "That’s Who I Praise" and Colton Dixon's "Up and Up"—were too religious. Teacher Penny Bishop reportedly told the kids' mom one song was too "Christian-based" for the event, citing concerns about church-state separation. Principal Molly Carl also objected, especially to lyrics referencing being freed from slavery, a nod to the biblical Exodus story.

Carl reportedly cautioned one student that "not everyone believes in God," and after approving the songs for auditions, she told one sibling the song would need to be "adjustable" for the May 23 event if deemed too religious.

That’s when First Liberty Institute, a legal advocacy group, stepped in, warning the school that banning the songs could violate the students' First Amendment rights. They gave the district a deadline to allow the siblings to participate with their chosen songs, just like their classmates.

The school district quickly reversed course, confirming that students can perform songs with religious content—as long as the lyrics stick to the student code of conduct. Crisis averted, the siblings will now get their moment in the spotlight, worship lyrics and all.

Superintendent Antoine added the school is reviewing its communication processes to avoid future confusion and emphasized their commitment to supporting students' diverse talents. Meanwhile, First Liberty counsel Kayla Toney praised the speedy resolution and suggested the district train staff on religious freedom in public schools. After all, nothing says "teachable moment" like a talent show controversy.